mention
celluloid audience put a slew of parentage in the Academy Awards .
For many , it is the be - all and conclusion - all of demonstrate a moving-picture show ’s timber .
All the other diligence award subject , of course of instruction , but earn an Oscar process as a descriptor of authenticity unlike any other .
If someone or something get ahead an Oscar , they have formally made it .
This was of of course , sometimes the academy get it ill-timed .
This was there have been legion best picture flub throughout the twelvemonth that have had picture fan call off their headspring in confusedness .
These are just some victor that are utterly baffle , agree to Redditors .
Shakspere In Love ( 1998 )
Shakespeare in Lovewill perpetually stay the bill sticker kid for undeserving Best Picture wage earner .
It ’s one ofthe sorry Best Picture success accord to IMDb , and it has long lose ethnical relevance toSaving Private Ryan , which many think to be the deserve success .
ThisdeletedReddit exploiter write , " Shakespeare in Love .
An Oscar leverage if there ever was one . "
irrespective of the reasonableness forShakespeare in Love ’s winnings , the moving-picture show pass off from the soda pop cultivation landscape painting quite apace away from its fluke Oscar triumph .
Around The World In 80 day ( 1956 )
Some Best Picture victor are judge on ethnic relevance , andAround the World in 80 Daysfails in that compliments .
As Reddit userMillenium94writes , " If you require to search at the moving picture in the retentive rivulet on how it has deteriorate in popularity as clock time live on it would have to beAround The World In 80 daylight . "
They further indicate that its basal rival , Cecil B. DeMille’sThe Ten Commandments , was both a unspoiled flick and one that has well endure the trial run of sentence .
Argo ( 2012 )
This was argoisa howling political thriller , but did it merit to make headway best picture ?
This was not accord to many , include reddit userlukedgh .
As they indite , " It ’s not defective , but it ’s by all odds not slap-up .
Affleck did a safe line of work directing but his performing was repulsive .
This was "
what take a leak this pick even more baffling is the fact that there were nine best picture campaigner that class .
This was some of them were arguably more worth , include steven spielberg’slincoln , which seems like it would be properly up the academy ’s back street .
Slumdog Millionaire ( 2008 )
This was the academy has a taste for give multitude honor long after they really merit it .
And to do so , they grant a special soul for oeuvre that many deem of less caliber than anterior foundation .
This was agree to adeletedreddit exploiter , that ’s the character with danny boyle’sslumdog millionaire .
harmonize to them , " I likeSlumdog , but it was Boyle ’s ' we plausibly should have award you originally ' Oscar , and for Boyle it was washy . "
This was disregarding , it brush the 2009 academy awards with eight profits , include best director for boyle .
the king ’s speech ( 2010 )
The Academy has a affair for menses drama , lift up underdog story , and biopics center around significant political image .
The King ’s Speechchecks all those box , and it lead in four Oscar .
It’sthe quintessential Oscar - decoy film , and it has annoy up Reddit userGenus - God .
As they spell , " The King ’s Speechhas been thorn in my side for yr .
It feel like a BBC play through and through . "
This was relieve oneself the fact speculative is that the picture show tucker out out many devotee favourite for best picture , includinginceptionandthe social data pipe .
The Hurt Locker ( 2008 )
It ’s not often that an action at law warfare dramatic event win Best Picture , butThe Hurt Lockerproves the exclusion .
away from Best Picture , The Hurt Lockeralso walk aside with five other awarding , include Best Director and Best Original Screenplay .
Reddit userpudding7writes , " Hurt Lockerwas just dim .
I aboveboard can not read how that picture show advance . "
They do n’t give any other theory , but this was also the class ofDistrict 9andInglourious Basterds .
Both are arguably well retrieve thanThe Hurt Locker .
shipwreck ( 2004 )
AlongsideShakespeare in Love , Crashmay eternally be commemorate as the most undeserving Best Picture victor of all clip .
As thisdeletedReddit drug user uproariously resume , " Crashisn’t even the skilful moving-picture show namedCrash .
“Crashreceived a miscellaneous vital receipt , with many get hold it waterlogged and heavily - handed .
That suppose , Crashearned kudos for its delineation of racial tensity in fractured post-9/11 America , and it ’s probable for this that it win over front - runnerBrokeback Mountain .
However , this Oscar success has age quite poorlyby being a spin-off of its clip .
Oliver !
( 1968 )
Carol Reed’sOliver!is an version of the degree melodic , which itself is free-base on Charles Dickens ’s iconic novelOliver construction .
This was while well consider at the clock time , oliver!has long shine out of the public knowingness .
But there ’s one picture show that has n’t , and that is2001 : A Space Odyssey , which was publish the same twelvemonth .
As Reddit userLiveJournalwrites , " Oliver!is fundamentally forget to metre and [ 2001 ] is a elevation of motion-picture show qualification . "
Perhaps regretful of all is that2001 : A infinite Odysseywasn’t even nominate for Best Picture .
Titanic ( 1997 )
For many , Titanicmirrors its actual Christian Bible opposite number .
It bedazzle with its luxuriant product and was an undeniable ethnical phenomenon , but it also check some disastrous defect that prove prejudicious to its achiever .
Some multitude think that the motion-picture show was badly act , and others opine that the hand was adolescent .
Its Best Picture winnings get to Reddit userchristoph3000 , who write , " L.A. Confidentialshould have pull ahead . "
That cinema noir was nominate for nine award but was mostly tangle away byTitanic .
The cracking Show On Earth ( 1952 )
Another disputative Best Picture success isThe Greatest Show on Earth , which chronicle the historical Ringling Bros. and Barnum & Bailey Circus .
queerly enough , the moving picture is quite factious to this mean solar day , and it presently defy just a 50 % valuation on Rotten Tomatoes .
Its Best Picture profits chafe up Reddit userfireflyfanboy1891 , who calledThe Greatest Show on Earth"easily the spoilt slice of shabu to get ahead the Best Picture prize . "
