Related
Summary
TheDivergentseries failed to achieve the same commercial-grade success and critical plaudits as its predecessor , theHunger Gamessaga , and there are some reasons why . Divergentfollows Shailene Woodley ’s Beatrice " Tris " Prior , the counterpart of Jennifer Lawrence ’s Katniss Everdeen , in a fellowship where people are divided into factions based on core personality trait . TheDivergentbooks by Veronica Roth closely followedThe Hunger Gamestaking off and were initially very popularamong fans of the former serial , but the movies never reached their full potency .
There are several grounds why theHunger Gamesmovieswere more successful than theDivergentfranchise , include writing quality , faithfulness to the ledger , and opportunities for gifted cast extremity to glisten . However , theDivergentseries also fall flat for reasons outside the moviemakers ' mastery . The compounding of those exit result in a fourthDivergentmovie never happening , with the saga never receiving a proper conclusion on silver screen .
relate : The Hunger Games Franchise ’s Complete Timeline Explained
6Hunger Games Was More Faithful To Its Books Than Divergent
Hunger Games Was A Better Adaptation.
While theHunger Gamesmovies eliminated some record book tantrum because of limited covert time , they keep up the overall plot ofSuzanne Collins’Hunger Gamesbooks . Quicker way for characters to get from one point to another that require less exposition are indite . For illustration , Katniss acquires her Mockingjay PIN number from a trafficker at the blackened securities industry alternatively of from her friend Madge as she does in the book , so the movie does not have to expend meter explaining who Madge is . But the core parts of the story stay . On the other manus , the secondDivergentmovie introduce original component that do not come across well .
A large part ofInsurgent(2015 ) is dedicated to a deep box incorporate a content from the city ’s founders that can only be opened by a finical Divergent , or a person who meet into more than one personality category . While the books do suggest that Tris is different from other Divergents because she parade trait of three categories rather than just two , the moving picture takes it too far by take in the evil Erudite faction possess twist to mensurate the percentage of one ’s departure . Insurgentturns into a video - game - mode plotwhere Tris has to pass a trial for each faction , even though she is not associated with Amity or Candor .
5The YA Genre’s Decreasing Popularity
Allegiant Came At The End Of The YA Dystopia Era.
As theHunger Gamesmovie serial ended , involvement in YA dystopias went down as audiences grew tired of stories that shared too many obvious element withThe Hunger Games.
For a few years , young adult dystopian narratives rule the book and movie industry . The Hunger Gamesnot only inspiredDivergent , butThe Maze Runnerby James Dashneras well . Any property in this genre drew legions of devotee and made for promise movie informatics . However , as theHunger Gamesmovie serial ended , interest in YA dystopias went down as interview grow timeworn of stories that shared too many obvious element withThe Hunger Games.
The Hunger Gameshad the welfare of hoopla because it inspired the musical genre ’s popularity and was arguably the first major global bang to come out of this fussy genre . The finalDivergentmovie , Allegiant(2016 ) , came out at the death YA dystopian era . The finalMaze Runnermovie get along out two age later and deal to move around a gain , but still did not live up to the height ofThe Hunger Games . However , partially because of the timing , Allegiantbombed at the box officeand the discuss plan to make a television receiver movie of the last installment , Ascendentwas finally call off .
4Divergent’s Narration Approach Didn’t Work
The Franchises Approached First-Person Narration Differently.
Both theHunger GamesandDivergentbooks are narrated in the first personbyKatniss and Trisrespectively , with the finalDivergentbook alternating between Tris and her collaborator Tobias Eaton ( Theo James ) . However , the firstHunger Gamesmovie cast out the story . alternatively , it uses opening form of address lineup , additional dialogue , and having the role player show rather than tell , to give the audience additional plot details that Katniss explains in the book .
On the other mitt , theDivergentmovie retain some of Tris ' narration , including her explicate the faction system and express her dilemma over which faction to choose for herself . The introduction would have been less forced if the movie had followedThe Hunger Games ' example of an orifice title carte for cosmos - edifice , instead of experience Tris explain it for no one ’s welfare except the audience . Additionally , Woodley , like Lawrence , is an Oscar - nominated actress who does not postulate expressed dialogueto establish that she is diffident of her future , especially since choose one faction in which to spend the rest of her life is manifestly a trying conclusion .
3Hunger Games Used Its Cast Better
Divergent did not use their A-listers well.
The popularity ofThe Hunger Gamesmanaged to attract an telling hurl to play the grownup characters , including Woody Harrelson , Elizabeth Banks , Lenny Kravitz , Donald Sutherland , Philip Seymour Hoffman , Julianne Moore , and Mahershala Ali . TheDivergentseries features Kate Winslet , Ashley Judd , Naomi Watts , Octavia Spencer , Daniel Dae Kim , and Maggie Q. However , Divergentdid not give its all - star cast the prospect to show off .
TheHunger Gamessaga include more adult theatrical role who are ally of the young adult graphic symbol , allowing for more nuanced interactions . Harrelson plays Katniss and Peeta Mellark ’s ( Josh Hutcherson ) mentor , Banks their escort Effie Trinket , and Kravitz Katniss ' stylist Cinna . Katniss even has some subtle , challenging give-and-take with Sutherland , who plays the main villain President Snow . InDivergent , the honest-to-god mould play villain whose aspect are reign by Tris and Tobias shout at them , parent and mentor who pop the question generic advice , or other character who have minimum use . None of them have the dialogue to agree their endowment .
2Divergent’s Failed Fourth Movie Promise
When the two-part movie trend stops working.
It was briefly common for the terminal installment in a series to be split into two movies . J. K. Rowling’sHarry Potter and the Deathly Hallowscertainly included enough textile for two movies . Stephenie Meyer’sBreaking DawnandMockingjaynot so much , but the hoopla surrounding these franchises made them profitable . However , by the end of theDivergentseries , it was exculpated that the two - part flick finale was only a hard currency - take hold of scheme . IfDivergenthad recognized that the YA dystopia hype was dying down and envelop thing up was for the proficient , more citizenry might have been able-bodied to uncritically enjoyAllegiant , knowing that it would be the last movie .
1Divergent & Hunger Games Never Had The Same Potential
Divergent just isn’t as good as The Hunger Games.
While the big YA tropes such as a love triangle , a strong main heroine , and a rising against a corrupted arrangement do make up a large part of theHunger Gamessaga , the Koran still let in allusions to bigger ideas about human nature and tyrannical governance , which are denigrate but allude upon in the picture show . The Hunger Gamesis inspire by various movies , Book , and historic events . The phrase"Panem et circenses,“for which the state of Panem is named , have-to doe with to the idea of appeasing a population with nutrient and entertainment in exchange for control and originated in ancient Rome .
Divergentis base on an implausible scenario where society has descend to accept that citizenry canonlybe honest , brave , tolerant , etc . , and only very rarely present more than one trait . It necessitate an evil government for the youthful champion to rebel against , but it has almost no implication in the veridical world . Divergentultimately never had the chance of matchingThe Hunger Games ' achiever as a picture series , although it could surely have been at least more successful than it was had some things been done good .
