Related
Summary
Although they have their similarity , the establishedStar Warstimeline seems to work better than theMCU ’s . With both Lucasfilm and Marvel Studios each sustain large interconnect franchises tying all of their films and demonstrate together as overarching tale , it ’s rather impressive to look at all they ’ve both reach . However , neither is without its flaw , thoughStar Warsdoes seem to have a more rich persistence overall .
wonder Studios and Lucasfilm have both release timeline guide only within a few months of each other in 2023 . DK’sStar Wars Timelineswas released in April whileMarvel Studios The Marvel Cinematic Universe An Official Timelinereleased in October . As such , it ’s worth comparing the two timelines using prescribed materials from both studios . Each offers classical date and fundamental insights into their respective continuity , though there are also decisive divergence in the anatomical structure as well as how each franchise has choose to handle any inaccuracies or contradiction . Here ’s a comparison of both timeline and the key reasons whyStar Wars’timeline seems to work the adept .
relate : How To look out Star Wars Movies In Order
How Do Star Wars' & Marvel’s Timelines Compare?
Very Similar in Scope And Size
Because both of these authoritative timeline guide have been free by the same publishing firm , the books themselves are quite standardized in their layout and construction . As each book move on throughout the years , there are also full spreads that break up down specific timeline result for certain quality , effect , or fundamental target . This let in Marvel ’s Battle of New York , Sabine Wren ’s Mandalorian Armor , and the history ofSpider - Man ’s costumes in the MCU .
TheStar Wars Timelinesbook has a standard baseline running through the heart of its pages , stand for its Congress of Racial Equality timeline with various upshot pointing to their position on the main line based on the year and sequence of events . There are also pages where multiple baselines are sport when primal events are happening at the same time like during Order 66 . However , the Marvel book ’s personal credit line is in fact the glow blue Sacred Timeline as it ’s been visually depicted in the MCU . While the scout is mostly set only to the outcome of the Sacred Timeline as a result , it does have key moments where temporal loop and arm were created .
Both of the templet are as comprehensive as reader would expect them to be . However , some of the more recent projects from both franchises are logically not have . The Marvel Word of God ’s present ends with the events ofWerewolf by Nightand theGuardians of the GalaxyHolidaySpecial . Meanwhile , Star Wars’present terminate with the events ofThe wage hike of Skywalker , and some of the more late projection such asThe Mandalorianseason 3 andAhsokaduring the preceding High Republic Era are not featured ( having come out after the usher ’s publishing ) .
How The Star Wars & MCU Timelines Deal With Continuity Problems
Certain Points of View vs Red Line Alerts
The Star Wars and MCU timelines care persistence errors in very different ways . For example , theStar Warsbook cautiously avoids issues with the multiple accounts of howKanan Jarrus survived Order 66as was seen in the comics and then other than inThe Bad Batchanimated serial publication . rather , a more general government note is made that Kanan fled into the woods after the expiry of his master , running from the troopers he once fought aboard ( which is rightful for both adaptation ) . It shows thatStar Warstends to take the classic"from a sure point of view,“mindset , not really mind which rendering viewing audience like so long as the basics are dealt with when contradictions do happen .
In contrast , the Marvel book ’s approach usesLoki’sMiss minute to call out continuity misplay as " Red Line Alerts " , admitting that some of them are unimaginable to solve and chalking them up to data debut errors made by TVA analyst . These are tacit entree that the MCU has stumbled at time , one of the most crying moments being the"8 geezerhood later " card at the commence ofSpider - Man : Homecomingeven though the clip betweenAvengersandHomecomingwas only 4 long time . While the admission are admittedly charming in their own way , it suggest that the MCU is not as keen when it come to retcons and attempting to correct past mistakes .
New Releases Are Causing Problems For Both Star Wars & The MCU
9 ABY and The Marvels Are Great Examples
It should also be note that late releases from both franchises are keep to create problems despite these Modern timeline books that have just been released . ForStar Wars , the equivocal placement of events fence the twelvemonth 9 ABY . This would be all the New Republic shew that have been released , though there have been infringe report regarding the placement ofThe Mandalorianseason 3 and the concurrent result ofAhsoka . While a definitive sequence of events could be delimitate , the ambiguity arguably plays in Lucasfilm ’s favour as there have been questions regarding the handing over of time followingThe Mandalorianseason 2 and Ahsoka ’s quest for Thrawn .
Likewise , The Marvelscreates issues for the MCU ’s timeline . Although the motion picture is meant to take place after theSecret Invasionshow pose in 2026 , Kamala Khan is still 16 and Kate Bishop is 23 which datesThe Marvelsas being put in 2025 . As a result , it would make the most sense forSecret Invasionto be retconned and moved back to 2025 , though it remains to be view if the MCU will regain a means of doing so . However , The Marvelshad its fair portion of firing delays so perhaps the original intention was to have it premier forward ofSecret Invasion .
touch on : How To Watch the Marvel Movies In Order ( By Release Date & In Order Of MCU Timeline Events )
Star Wars Has A Longer History Of Handling Timelines
They’ve Got The Experience
Ultimately , Star Warsis a amply trans - medium franchise with comic , novels , and video games all being part of the established canon and timeline , while Marvel only has to deal movies and show . Likewise , Star Warshas been ramp up its timeline for almost 50 years across two iterations of the canon . Marvel Studios has only been at it for 15 . While there are surely pros and yardbird to both , it can surely be argued thatStar Wars’longevity has helped it cultivate a more robust timeline overall .
This is fundamentally whyStar Wars’timeline works comfortably in equivalence . The timeline has always been important , and Lucasfilm seems to have had a longstanding philosophical system of finding ways to retcon repugnance when contradiction do happen across their decades of real - time history . This leads to a more cohesive timeline on the whole , whereas Marvel Studios ' MCU still feels new and stumbling , perhaps being more cautious as it ’s the new timeline of the two with less experience . no matter , both timeline guides are well worth the read and must - rich person forStar WarsandMCUfans alike .
