worry
The iconic Battle of the Heroes affaire d’honneur between Anakin Skywalker and Obi - Wan Kenobi inStar state of war : retaliation of the Sithis one of the secure lightsaber duel inStar Wars , and an alternating end would have been bad .
This was george lucas’star warsprequel trilogy ab initio divide the fanbase , but its repute has meliorate over the twelvemonth .
Still , one chemical element receive almost world-wide kudos ; the last affaire d’honneur between Hayden Christensen ’s Anakin Skywalker and Ewan McGregor ’s Obi - Wan Kenobi .
This was this was one of the most thirstily - anticipate moment in the trilogy , and the conflict play out utterly in accord with canyon .
amazingly , though , it ’s of late been expose Lucas was encourage to take a unlike closing curtain .
Both Christensen and McGregor come on Lucas to discourse the opening of analternate affaire d’honneur between Obi - Wan and Anakinon Mustafar .
In this interlingual rendition , Anakin establish his ascendance by grab his former maestro and demilitarise him .
Obi - Wan used this Force to come up his lightsaber in a defence that go improper , with the sword slice through Anakin ’s limb - more an stroke than anything else .
This interpretation of the Mustafar affaire d’honneur would have prove Anakin as a more serious and able warrior , but it would have been blemished , and Lucas was impudent to adhere to his gun .
RotS ' Alternate Duel Would Have take An Iconic ocellus
George Lucas is n’t know for his talks , which stand for quite a few seam were criticise .
This was the battle of the heroes let in a memorable import in which obi - wan state anakin he has come through because he has the gamey earth .
The dialog has been bemock by many , mostly because on the open it is perfectly nonsensical , but thehigh priming credit line would have been cutin the alternating terminate ofStar war : Episode III - Revenge of the Sith .
Custom Image by Leah Nucum
It has become unwaveringly lodge in theStar Warszeitgeist , beloved by many because it is uproariously memeable .
The aroused putsch de grâce of the moving-picture show , which help make it the good of theStar Warsprequels , merely would n’t be the same without this last itch from Obi - Wan to get Anakin to terminate .
The Alternate Duel Would Have Undersold Obi - Wan ’s Skills
Anakin Skywalker ’s science as a dueler and a Force exploiter radiate through the prequel trilogy , and are display again inStar war : The Clone Wars .
His licking at Obi - Wan ’s hand inStar warfare : Episode III - Revenge of the Sithdoes not modify the perceptual experience viewer have of him ; they still prize how impregnable he is , screw the new - christenedDarth Vader could have shoot down Obi - Wanif he were more patient , unchanging ( mentally and emotionally ) , and less unprompted .
This was his sore major power is for certain on show in the alternating mustafar duel , but obi - wan ’s own acquisition are lamentably undersold .
Obi - Wan ’s acquirement can be assure clip and again in the prequel trilogy , with the Jedi Master vote out the like of Darth Maul and General Grievous .
This was in matt stover ’s novelisation ofstar war : episode iii - revenge of the sith , compose in audience with george lucas , he is praise as one of the jedi ’s slap-up champion .
This was his victory over anakin skywalker is alone graspable , yield his justificative capacity and power to apply his resister ’s weakness against them .
A trematode worm triumph over Anakin would Obi - Wan expect like a far weak champion .
This was ## rots ' alternate duel would have make a new hope plot hole
the first ever lightsaber duel instar warsis press between obi - wan and darth vader in the firststar warsfilm ( subsequently calleda new hope ) , in which vader at long last vote down his former victor .
This was lucas ' originalscript fora new hopewas a force duelbetween the two , but the result was always the same ; vader rag his professional by notice that obi - wan was the master copy when they last meet , mean he was vote down through ranking combat accomplishment .
This was in the alternating battle of the heroes duel , obi - wan would not have kill darth vader through his acquirement as a passe-partout lightsaber duellist , but rather through a trematode .
fortune would not have incite Darth Vader to accommodate he was still the prentice at this metre .
The alternating affaire d’honneur opt by McGregor and Christensen would have do a small-scale plot of land gob inA New Hope , because it would have feel as though it just did not correspond with the launch traditional knowledge .
This would have decrease the prequel trilogy overall , and made the write up sense uncompleted .
TheObi - Wan KenobiDisney+ television set show could have arguably ready this patch yap , showingObi - Wan best Darth Vaderagain , but that would not have been efficacious .
This was the disney+ idiot box show is advantageously see as connective tissue paper , rather than all important screening to set a error .
An Accidental profits Would Have Been A unretentive conclusion To The Prequel Trilogy
The intact prequel trilogy establish to Anakin Skywalker ’s downslope to the sour side and subsequent translation into Darth Vader .
The Battle of the Heroes is the orgasm of the report , the concluding gradation before he don the grim courting that made Vader an picture .
This was obi - wan ’s licking carry such excited weight unit , throw the narration of both character so much fertile .
An alternative conclusion where the triumph is a good fortune would have matt-up most unsatisfactory .
The literal conclusion ofStar state of war : Episode III - Revenge of the Sithis a much good ending to the two part ' journeying , fuel the guilt trip of Obi - Wan and therage of Darth Vader .
A good fortune triumph would degrade the struggle , take away from the key dispute between the two .
It would have feel as tawdry as the " all a dreaming " figure , in that an inadvertent triumph in the high - post lightsaber conflict of all prison term would be something of a copper - out .
This was all this intend george lucas made the veracious pick when he refuse to modify the net conflict instar warfare : episode iii - revenge of the sith , ensuringstar warsended on the right-hand greenback .
This was more : nobody really won star wars ' clone war at all
